| Good morning. I’m Chris Giles, FT economics commentator. I no longer think it is rude to call me a veteran of UK Budget analysis. In any Budget, you have to answer four questions: what economic circumstances did the chancellor face; what was the Budget judgment; who were the winners and losers; and what does this mean for UK politics. And all the time you must not get lost in the weeds of the measures. This year answering the first question is easy. The Office for Budget Responsibility decided to make only one big change to its forecast from March and that was incorporating the effects of the Middle East war. This has raised energy prices and government borrowing costs worldwide. For the UK, the effect is simple. As a net energy importer, higher costs of oil and gas have made us poorer as a country, so it was inevitable that John Healey’s main job was distributing the losses. The chancellor’s Budget judgment was to allow deficit reduction to slip again. The UK is still planning to get borrowing down to sustainable levels, but this is later than previously planned and the slippage averages 0.4 per cent of GDP a year to 2030-31, so borrowing will be £13bn higher on average each year than forecast. Much more delay and Labour cannot claim to be serious about deficit reduction. As for who loses, my little list sums up who pays. Your children. Additional borrowing means future generations will be paying the interest on £70bn more debt by 2030-31 than expected in the previous March forecasts. You and other members of your household. The only way for the OBR to make the economic numbers add up was to assume that prices would be 2.5 per cent higher by the end of the decade than it expected in March, while pay would not match that increase. That is why the OBR thinks real household disposable income will take a 0.75 per cent hit by the end of the decade, again compared with its March forecast. Lower real incomes outweigh any “breathing space” measures such as £100 off energy bills and delays in petrol duty increases. Public services. The budgets for public services are set in cash terms, so higher inflation will eat away at government departments’ spending power. Did you hear Healey say he was an austerity chancellor? No, nor did I. Banks. They will pay a little extra in profit taxes, which will be passed on to shareholders, customers and staff. But £1.5bn over a 15-month run is not a lot of money. They lost the battle on taxation but won a wider war about the burden they should carry. Companies with second-hand assets. Much more money was raised here than from banks. The reduction of the writing-down rate of corporate tax capital allowances from 14 per cent to 12 per cent will raise £1bn a year. See Dan Neidle for more. Savers and landlords. The tax surcharge on rental income rises another 2 percentage points to 4 percentage points from April. This is where the Burnham government is most rapidly going back to the 1970s. Back then, the investment income surcharge was 15 per cent and it could lead to a 98 per cent tax rate, although in practice it just led to tax avoidance. Workers. Obviously, as wages partially try to chase inflation higher, workers will pay more income tax at a time when allowances and thresholds are frozen until the 2030s. Never underestimate the power of fiscal drag.
In contrast to the losers, I think the main winners from this Budget are accountants and tax lawyers. To have 98 small measures in the Treasury scorecard for one Budget is a gift to all those who profit from tax complexity. It was because the losers were so clear and the winners were so few that I thought Kemi Badenoch’s response to the Budget was so strange. The Conservative leader spent 27 minutes not pointing out who was losing and not pinning it on Andy Burnham and Healey. Of course, had she done so, that would not have been fair, but when was politics fair? It was a bizarre performance. The final political question is whether this brings an election closer. I doubt it. This was a Budget that spread pain far and wide. Healey used his blunderbuss rather than a rifle. However poor the political response from the Conservative leader, you do not want to go to the country when you’ve just made everyone worse off (even if you were not to blame). As an economist, I have been asked repeatedly whether I have seen and loved The Standard of Living, James Graham’s new blockbuster play about John Maynard Keynes and the Bloomsbury Group. I have seen it. If you love a mash-up between a Wikipedia page and the film Dead Poets Society with a relentless “carpe diem” message, buy tickets. If you think that sounds a bit simplistic for a complex world, you might, like me, find it a bit irritating but not boring. Join Lucy Fisher, George Parker, Katie Martin, Sam Fleming and Jennifer Williams for a webinar examining the political and economic choices unveiled in the Budget. It’s today at 1pm. |